NEWS
NEWS
More details of the 2-year-old girl's death case revealed that the elevator door was only open for 6 seconds when the windowsill was less than half a meter high.
2024-05-14
author：
Page view：
More details of the 2-year-old girl's death case revealed that the elevator door was only open for 6 seconds when the windowsill was less than half a meter high.
Recently, Hangzhou "2-year-old girl was left in the elevator by the nanny, and then fell from the 8th floor", causing widespread concern.
On June 28, Nandu reporter noticed that in the surveillance video made public by the girl's father, the girl was left alone in the elevator,It took only about 6 seconds for the elevator door to go from fully open to fully closed. In addition, the Nandu reporter interviewed a number of industry insiders, lawyers, a construction industry analysis,The main problem at the scene of the accident is that the safety protection railings are not set up in this area according to the specifications..
Lawyer of Guangdong Guoding Law FirmLiao JianxunTell the Nandu reporter that there is a serious dereliction of duty in the nanny's behavior, which may constitute the crime of negligence causing death.
Previously reported
2-year-old girl falls to death after being left in elevator, police intervene
Lawyer says nanny involved in serious dereliction of duty
According to Nandu's previous report, Mr. Chen, the father of the girl who died, said the child was less than 22 months old at the time of the accident. The surveillance video disclosed by it showed that on the evening of June 14, the nanny involved went out to take the elevator. After arriving on the first floor, the nanny involved pulled the scooter out of the elevator,When the elevator door was about to close, it was discovered that the child did not get out of the elevator. Attempts to prevent the elevator from closing failed. The child was left alone in the elevator..
Subsequently, after the elevator automatically rose to the 8th floor, the elevator door opened again, Cherry walked out of the elevator, and then disappeared into the monitoring range. Mr. Chen said,After the child got out of the elevator, he accidentally fell from the window on the 8th floor to the cement platform on the 2nd floor, and died after rescue..
for this matter,Mr. Chen believes that the nanny involved has an inescapable responsibility.. He said that in the elevator, the nanny involved had not taken protective measures such as holding, holding, letting, and protecting the child, resulting in him being left alone in the elevator. The babysitter involved didn't contact him by phone until 8 minutes after the child fell from the building, and failed to tell the truth about the incident, which delayed the search work. The child was found more than half an hour after the child fell from the building, missing the best rescue time.
In response to Mr. Chen's allegations, Liao Jianxun, a lawyer at Guangdong Guoding Law Firm, said that from the surveillance video,There was a serious dereliction of duty in the nanny's conduct..Because the object of her care is a child under the age of 2, who is completely incapable of civil conduct, she should fulfill the necessary and proper care obligations.
"It was her negligence that caused the young child to be left alone in the elevator, which eventually led to the consequences of falling to death,Therefore, her actions may be suspected of causing death by negligence.." Liao Jianxun analyzed to a reporter from Nandu that if it is finally determined to constitute the crime of negligence causing death, then according to the provisions of the Criminal Law, the nanny involved may be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of not less than three years and not more than seven years. Of course, if the circumstances are relatively minor, they may be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of up to three years.
"Even if it is finally determined that the nanny involved does not constitute the crime of negligence causing death, legally speaking, her behavior is also a tort with serious fault." liao jianxun believes that under such circumstances,The family of the girl who fell to her death may require the nanny to bear the liability for tort damages..
The elevator door will close after only 6 seconds
Insiders: usually ten seconds
The Southern Metropolis reporter noticed that in response to this matter, in addition to the controversy over the negligence of the nanny involved, many netizens also questioned that the elevator was closing too fast. As soon as the nanny involved walked out of the elevator, the door was closed, resulting in the inability to take the child out in time.
Nandu reporter found from Mr. Chen's public surveillance video that at about 20:05 on the day of the incident, the elevator reached the first floor, the elevator door was fully opened at about 20:5:10, and the elevator door was completely closed at about 20:5:16,Only about six seconds passed,The elevator doors remain fully open for only 3 or 4 seconds.
Nandu reporter found that in the current national standard "elevator technical conditions" (GB/T 10058-2009), there is no stipulation on the length of time the elevator can be kept open. Master Zeng, a technical employee of an elevator company, told reporters in Nandu,The length of time the elevator remains open can be adjusted, generally within the range of 20 seconds to 180 seconds..
"There is no standard at present. We set it up according to the requirements of customers. Some elevators have no one to take. It is not good to stop for too long after opening the door. Generally speaking, the passenger elevator keeps the door open for more than ten or twenty seconds.It is rare to drive for only five or six seconds, but there is no specific standard to say that this is not possible."Master Zeng said.
Industry insiders said:
The main problem is that there is no protective fence at the site.
The Nandu reporter also noticed that in response to this incident, many netizens questioned that the height of the windowsill on the 8th floor of the accident site was too low, causing a child under 2 years old to easily climb up.
In response to netizens' doubts about the height of the windowsill, Ms. Zheng, an employee of the design department of a real estate company in Guangzhou, told Nandu reporters that judging from the videos and pictures currently disclosed,The main problem at the scene of the accident is that the safety protection railings are not set up in this area according to the specifications..
There are media reports,The bottom cement table where the girl fell is about 0.49 meters high.. ms. zheng analyzed it with reporters from nandu,According to national standards, when the residential windowsill is less than 0.9 meters, protective measures should be taken. The incident place is located at the air window on the 8th floor. The height of the window sill is only 0.49 meters, far below 0.9 meters. Protective railings should be set up.
Nandu reporter inquired about a number of real estate intermediary platforms and learned that the completion time of the new building in Hangzhou United Century District, where the incident occurred, was 2008. Ms. Zheng told Nandu reporter that according to Article 2 of Item 6.6.3 of the General Principles for Design of Civil Buildings (GB50352-2005) implemented at that time, when the airport height is below 24m, the height of the railing should not be less than 1.05m, and when the airport height is 24m and above, the height of the railing should not be less than 1.1m.
Ms. Zheng explained to reporters in Nandu that the height of the railing should be calculated from the vertical height from the floor to the top of the railing. if the tread has a width greater than or equal to 0.22m and a height less than or equal to 0.45m, the height of the safety railing should be calculated from the top of the treadable part.
Ms. Zheng pointed out that judging from the current public videos and pictures, the windowsill on the 8th floor where the girl fell has the problem of not setting up safety protection railings according to the specifications.
Liao Jianxun believes that if the developer fails to carry out construction in accordance with the relevant norms and standards, the housing construction department can impose administrative penalties on it. If the construction does not meet the standards and causes the child to fall to death, the family members can sue the developer or the property company and ask them to bear certain tort liability.
According to Nandu's previous report, on June 28, the Hangzhou Public Security Bureau revealed that the public security department had been involved in the investigation in the early stage. The property of the community involved told Nandu reporters that recently, local public security, market supervision and other departments have carried out daily investigations on the spot, including verifying the developer's design drawings and elevator problems.
Source: Phoenix New Media, Southern Metropolis Daily
If there is infringement, contact Li delete
Keywords:
AVIC Elevator Equipment, AVIC Elevator, Elevator Sales, AVIC Elevator Sales, Elevator Maintenance
Contact us
Address: Emei Mountain Road, Gaoping Industrial Park, Huichuan District, Zunyi City
Public account
Mobile terminal
Copyright © 2024 CHINA AVIATION GUIZHOU ELEVATOR CO.,LTD All Rights Reserved